Isidro Ramirez explores two different areas of learning (in a physical
and
literal sense), which could be viewed as being examples of both sites
of
'training' and 'personal development'. Looking at the series of
pictures,
what is striking is how 'anonymous' these spaces are. They were all
taken
shortly after students had vacated the room. There are traces of human
occupation in the way that a chair is placed, paper cup discarded or
notes
in brightly coloured marker pen are still attached to the board. Like
all
institutions, the spaces are 'muli-purpose'. They are inevitably
'anonymous': large amounts of people use them everyday. The flow of
knowledge from tutor to student (and vice versa) is as ethereal as the
process of people passing through here - people going on to 'bigger
better'
things. These are transitional spaces. They are places where some of
the
most profound evens in our lives occur: birth, death and learning.
The similarities between the two sites of learning which Ramirez
examines
are extended beyond their initial aesthetics. Are the model heads in
the
lecture theatre part of an anatomy lesson or a drawing lesson? Is the
apparatus medical or technical? The room in the London Institute of
Education could just as easily be part of a casualty ward with its
screens
and curtains (a physical examination room, rather than a mental
examination
room). The photographs reinforce the familiarity of these spaces - we
have
all been hare at one time or another in our lives.
But the photographs' perceptible neutrality belies their subject'
purpose.
In these brown walled, strip-lit rooms, a process takes place which is
far
from neutral, as Paulo Friere states'...there is no such thing as a
neutral
education process. Education either functions as an instrument which is
used
to facilitate the integration of generations into the logic of the
present
system and bring conformity to it, or it becomes 'the practice of
freedom',
the means by which men and women deal critically and creatively with
reality
and discover how to participate in the transformation of their world.'
What is interesting about these sites is not so much 'What has
happened?'
but 'What happens next?' There is an anticipation in these seemingly
abandoned rooms where what has taken place seems to have finished. This
sense of expectation and possibility are the very qualities that
attract
people to sit in these unappealing places in their spar time. Ramirez's
impassive eye takes in the empty interiors but suggest human presence,
turning his camera back in on the spaces in which small epiphanies take
place every day.
©Text by Mellany Robinson for NextLevel Magazine, Edition 2 Vol 1 |